How To Negotiate A Discount

Have you ever noticed how some people are able to get great discounts on their investment property while others pay the asking price?
What’s their secret?
There’s really no secret – they’ve just learned how to negotiate well.
Of course the market will dictate how much of a discount you can expect – if the market cycle is at the bottom then you’ve got a great chance of getting a discount – more so than when it’s strong.
So let’s say you’ve found an investment property which could deliver a great return if the price is right and the vendor is really motivated.
One way to negotiate a discount is through the property’s condition. Using a checklist, deliver your offer to the agent categorising the repairs or issues with the investment property and attach a cost to each item deducting them from the asking price.
Be sure to include a buffer for each item to cover any price errors.
Use the following checklist for reference when creating your own. To streamline your negotiating efforts create a template which is generic enough to use on every deal, which you can tweak as needed:
| Checklist | Item(s) | Cost |
| 1. | External – strip and/or paint walls, repair brickworks | |
| 2. | Interior – walls and ceiling repair, paint, etc. | |
| 3. | Windows and doors – repair and/or replace (fly screens, broken glass, locks and catches), paint, etc. | |
| 4. | Repair and/or replace flooring and window fixtures and coverings. | |
| 5. | Repair and/or replace kitchen appliances, light fixtures, cupboards, exhaust fans, range hood, etc. | |
| 6. | Bathroom – repair and/or replace tiles, shower, toilet, taps, cupboard, mirror, vanity, etc. | |
| 7. | Will you need to add a bathroom or bedroom to be competitive in the market? | |
| 8. | Built in wardrobes, air conditioning, ensuite, fans, etc. | |
| 9. | Guttering and downpipe need replacing? | |
| 10. | Electrical and plumbing in good shape? | |
| 11. | Hot water system in good shape? | |
| 12. | Roof need replacing? | |
| 13. | Landscaping, letterbox in good repair? | |
| 14. | Exterior buildings in good shape? (e.g. granny flat) | |
| 15. | Steps and handrails, balcony railings | |
| 16. | Fencing, access, driveway, retaining walls in good condition? | |
| 17. | Pest issues, structural repairs needed, stumps need removed? | |
| 18. | Other |
Knowledge is key
Strong due diligence efforts are a key component of a successful negotiation strategy. You should know the market – and the property – inside and out before submitting your offer.
As part of your due diligence strategy contact other local agents in the area and discuss the investment property you’re considering. For example, you can call up Agent A and tell him, “I’ve put in an expression of interest with Agent B on the house at 125 Proffitt Street. Can you tell me anything about it or the area?”
It’s simply human nature. Chances are you’ll hear all of the “dirty secrets” about it, such as it’s always flooding, has termites or high crime. Depending upon what you hear you can then use this information as leverage when negotiating a discount with the vendor.
This strategy works much better than simply asking for a discount “because”. After all, if you saw these problems chances are good that another potential buyer would too, giving the vendor a legitimate reason for dropping his price.
Even if your conversation with Agent A doesn’t provide anything you can use for negotiation, that doesn’t mean you’ve wasted your time. It’s very possible that Agent A will discover, upon questioning you on the type of property you need, that he has similar – or even better – properties available.
In short, it pays to maintain a good relationship with a number of agents in the locations you’re interested in as you may have agents contacting you with deals that come across their desks – even before they hit the market!
Finally, “play nice”. Be fair and reasonable and it’s likely that the other party(ies) will cooperate and consider your needs as well. If possible, find any common ground (e.g. heritage, interests, etc) you may share to help strengthen your connections.
If you are interested in discussing similar matters with like-minded property investor people and professional coaches, feel free to join us at our next FREE Investor Property Night near you!
WCC 1014: The “Ghost Profit” Trap: Navigating Tax and Tensions in the 2026 Energy Shock
We are entering a "genuinely interesting" economic moment—the kind where an accountant’s phone call usually starts with bad news. With the conflict in the Middle East escalating and the Strait of Hormuz effectively restricted, oil prices and freight costs are surging...
WCC 967: How to Rebuild Wealth and Target $150K Passive Income
What does it really take to rebuild wealth after starting over? In this episode of Wealth Coffee Chats, we unpack a real-world Australian property investing journey focused on long-term strategy, risk management, and smart portfolio structuring. Learn how consistent...
WCC RBA Rate Hold & Inflation Outlook: What Investors Must Know
In this update, we unpack the RBA's latest decision to hold interest rates and explore what it means for investors moving forward. With inflation creeping up and unemployment rising, Alex breaks down the Reserve Bank’s statement, key economic indicators, and how they...
WCC Should You Buy Property with Friends or Family? Unit Trusts & Syndicate Investing Explained
Thinking about pooling funds to invest in property with others? In today’s episode, we unpack the increasingly popular strategy of syndicated investing—buying property as a group through structures like unit trusts. Discover how this approach gives you access to...
WCC Why Diversification is Your Best Investment Strategy in 2025
In today’s Wealth Coffee Chat, Senior Financial Adviser Alex dives into the only thing investors can truly control—asset allocation. Using Tesla’s surprising stock rally after poor earnings as a real-world example, Alex unpacks how market logic can defy investor...
WCC Real Estate Resolutions: Pay off Your Home in Under 10 Years and Save $400K in Interest
In this video Jason Whitton explains how with some simple, and FREE, changes to your mortgage strategy, you can pay off your home loan faster and start using equity to boost your borrowing power for your next property purchase. With the right tweaks you could pay off...
WCC Who Writes the Rules of Wealth?
In this Wealth Coffee Chat, Jason talks about the three groups that create the rules of wealth in Australia: politicians, banks, and regulators. He explains how these groups can affect your wealth and why it's important to know and understand the rules they set. Jason...
WCC There Are 3 Major Changes Coming for Qld Property Investors.
There are 3 significant changes to property management that are going into effect this week in Queensland; Rent bidding is being removed, the amount of rent paid in advance is changing and the biggest change will affect rent price increases.What does all this mean for...
WCC When Will Interest Rates Drop Here’s What Will Happen When They Do.
Here Jason Whitton explains the causal effects of rising interest rates and the highlights the huge gap between where Australia’s housing industry is currently at and where it needs to be. Most importantly Jason discusses what will happen when Australia's interest...
WCC Builders are going broke at record levels: What investors can do
These days construction costs have surged and it's taking longer to build homes! It doesn't take a lot to do due diligence and know what to do. Let's Wealth Coffee chat!